SHONGSHOY.ORG Independent reading editionArchived · 11 November 2026
THE COLLECTION

All articles

32 articles

32 articles found

Religion

Dhul Khalasa: How Islamic Jihad Destroyed a Pagan Pilgrimage Site

On Muhammad’s orders, Jarir’s forces tore down and burned Dhul Khalasa, the “Yemeni Kaaba,” and killed those they found there. Islamic sources record how a regional sanctuary was destroyed while Mecca’s Kaaba and selected pilgrimage rites were retained under Islam.

Editor's pick

Quran Compilation and Revision: Text, Power, and the Claim of Immutability

A critical examination of Quranic compilation, textual variants, competing mushafs, suppressed readings, and later revisions. Drawing on classical Islamic sources, it investigates how human decisions and political authority shaped the accepted text and challenges claims of its im

Editor's pick

Muta Marriage in Islam: Lawful Sexual Contracts and Ethical Contradictions

Islamic sources document muta marriage under Muhammad and its continuation until Umar’s prohibition. Conflicting reports, the Companions’ practices, and provisions concerning minors, paternity, maintenance and inheritance raise fundamental questions about consent, women’s rights

Religion

‘Mukhannath’ and ‘Khuntha’: Islamic Sharia Rulings on Hijras

An examination of mukhannath and khuntha in Islamic texts, tracing rulings on exile, social exclusion, employment, marriage, and inheritance, and assessing their implications for the dignity and rights of hijras and gender-diverse people.

Religion

The Quran Without Hadith: Can Islamic Sharia Function?

Traditional Islamic law depends on hadith for the interpretation and application of Quranic commands. From prayer and dietary rules to criminal punishments, hadith supplies details absent from the Quranic text. This dependence also raises questions about treating human transmissi

Editor's pick

Child Abuse in Islam: Corporal Punishment, Religious Authority, and Sharia Rulings

An examination of child abuse and corporal punishment in Islamic texts and jurisprudence. Drawing on hadiths, classical legal rulings, and scholarly fatwas, this article explores the religious justification of beating children, the authority granted to parents and teachers, legal

Editor's pick

Punishment for Rape under Islamic Sharia: The Dangerous Four-Witness Rule

This article critically examines rape laws in classical Islamic Sharia, exploring how the four-witness requirement, restrictions on women’s testimony, and limitations on forensic evidence can obstruct justice and expose victims to punishment.

Religion

Blasphemy, Sectarianism, and the Sunnah of Destroying Idols

An examination of blasphemy, religious intolerance, and idol destruction in Islamic scripture, prophetic biography, and classical jurisprudence, exploring the tension between demands for respect for Islam and the destruction of other religions’ sacred images and places of worship

Does “Da’if/Weak Hadith” Mean False? A Critical Examination of Hadith Grading

Does a weak hadith mean an event never happened, and does a sahih grading establish historical certainty? This article examines conflicting scholarly judgments, narrator reliability, legal practice and theological bias to explain why hadith grades require scrutiny of their eviden

Editor's pick

Umm Hani: Muhammad’s Secret Romance

Where was Muhammad on the night of the Mi‘raj? Examining conflicting accounts in hadith, sira, and tafsir alongside his relationship with Umm Hani, this article questions the traditional narrative and explores whether the story of a heavenly journey concealed a more personal enco